Perfect for tight lining - doesn’t smudge or giv free raccoon eyes by the end of the day. I’ve purchased this multiple times and finally got a subscription - worth every penny

I got this liner for my waterline. Although it did last for about 4 hours. it did end up smudging down my eyes after a while.

I’ve tried all the liners and this ONE is it! It’s the only liner that actually stays on and doesn’t smudge off under my eye. Every liner may say that it’s waterproof but you can trust them when they say waterproof lol. I use this and the liquid liner from KISSME, perfection! <3

It lasted longer than most eyeliners. Easy to glide on. The only problem is when I used artificial tears, it melted like all other waterproof eyeliners. Since I haven't found one that can withstand the artificial tears, I am not counting this against it. Overall, one of the better ones, I'd say but there are comparable ones that cost less.

It’s a very good liner and last a long time no problems at all