good and very very nice

Pretty good with withstanding water, does fade a teeny bit but nothing that wasn't expected. It is easy to take off as well, and it is appealing especially since it looks more natural with the brown-colored look.

Great liner, rich color, tip is not too skinny, not too thick. Stays put all day with no smudging!

I have Asian eyes and eyeliners are tough to find. Sure, could it be more pigmented, yes. But the smudging is more important to me than the darkness. So never going back to western brands

I've been using the eyeliner for a few months now, and I'm quite impressed with its performance. Here's a breakdown of my experience:

Packaging and Applicator:
The eyeliner comes in a sleek, attractive pen that’s easy to hold and use. The brush tip applicator is precise and flexible, allowing for a smooth application whether you’re going for a thin line or a bold cat eye. The cap clicks securely in place, ensuring the product doesn’t dry out.

Color and Finish:
The Brown Black shade is perfect for those who want a softer alternative to jet black. It’s a deep, rich brown with just enough darkness to define the eyes without looking too harsh. The finish is a beautiful balance between matte and satin, which adds a subtle sophistication to any look.

Application and Wear:
The formula glides on effortlessly without skipping or tugging, however, you will need to swipe on the back of your hand first to 'warm' up the product. It dries fairly quickly, preventing any smudging during application. One of the standout features is its staying power. This eyeliner stays put throughout the day but doesn't work well with sweats, humid days, and tears.

Value for Money:
At its price point, NYX is way cheaper and works just as well. However, this eyeliner would never leak or make a mess in your purse. That is the REAL value of this product. Also, the Ultra-thin tip makes the application a lot more precise and easy to create the looks I want.